George Orwell’s 1984 warned that authoritarian power ultimately demands one thing above all else: loyalty proven by denying reality itself. That warning is no longer abstract. From January 6 to the killing of Nicole Good by ICE, Americans are being asked to reject what they can plainly see and hear—and to treat that denial as a civic duty.
“The party told you to reject the evidence of your eyes and ears. It was their final, most essential command.”
—George Orwell, 1984
The second sentence is the point. Orwell was not describing secret propaganda or subtle mind control. He was describing a system in which truth becomes subordinate to loyalty. Once people can be trained to say that what is obvious is not real, power no longer needs to persuade. It only needs to insist.
That is the condition we are living in now.
Minnesota Governor Tim Walz has articulated this plainly: democracy depends on shared facts. Not shared ideology—shared reality. Without agreement on what actually happened, accountability collapses. That warning matters because recent events show how aggressively people are being pushed to abandon their own perception.
The Killing of Nicole Good and the Denial of Visible Evidence
Nicole Good was in her own neighborhood. She lived there.
ICE agents, unfamiliar with the area, became stuck in the snow. Neighbors, seeing federal agents immobilized on a residential street, believed an ICE action was underway and initiated a community patrol response. That is the factual context.
Video and footage from the scene show Nicole Good’s SUV stopped diagonally in the street during the ICE encounter, with agents approaching from both sides as she tries to move the vehicle away from them. As she begins to drive forward and turn to the right—moving away from the agents—shots are fired into her vehicle, striking her in the head while the car is already withdrawing. After the fatal shots, audio on the recording captures someone saying the word “bitch.”
This did not happen in secret.
The video exists.
The audio exists.
People can see it. People can hear it.
What ICE, Trump, Noem, and Vance Said Instead
Despite the video and audio evidence, federal officials immediately presented a different narrative.
ICE, DHS Secretary Kristi Noem, President Donald Trump, and Vice President J.D. Vance publicly described Nicole Good as a terrorist, claimed she “weaponized” her vehicle, and framed the killing as justified self-defense.
Those statements did not address the timing of the shots. They did not engage with the direction of the vehicle. They did not grapple with what the video shows. Instead, they required the public to override their own eyes and ears.
That is not political disagreement.
That is instruction.
January 6 and the Same Authoritarian Pattern
This demand to deny observable reality is not new.
After January 6, Americans watched hours of video showing a violent assault on the U.S. Capitol. Courts rejected claims of widespread election fraud. Election officials across parties certified the results. And yet people were told—repeatedly—that none of this meant what it plainly showed.
Accepting the evidence marked you as disloyal.
Rejecting it became a badge of belonging.
This is how modern authoritarian movements operate: not by hiding evidence, but by turning denial into a loyalty test.
Why Orwell Called This the Final Command
Force alone does not end a free society. People have resisted force throughout history.
What ends it is something else entirely: training people to deny reality as proof of allegiance.
In 1984, once citizens accept that their own senses cannot be trusted, there is nothing left to argue about. Evidence stops mattering. Truth stops limiting power. Everything becomes negotiable except obedience.
That is why Orwell called this the final, most essential command.
The People Are Still More Powerful Than the People in Power
Orwell did not believe authoritarian power was inevitable. He believed it depended on compliance.
The people in power are loud, armed, and relentless—but they are fewer than the people they govern. When ordinary people refuse to deny what they see, refuse to repeat what they know is false, and refuse to confuse obedience with safety, power loses its most effective weapon.
History does not turn because authority demands it. It turns because people decide they will no longer play along.
Join us for the NO KINGS 3 Valentine’s Day Kickoff—a gathering to connect, organize, and prepare for what comes next.
👉 Sign up here: NO KINGS 3 – Valentine’s Day Prep & Planning Kickoff
Organized by Queens Says No Kings.
